Monday, April 9, 2012

End of Act 2 - Questions to consider


In what ways does Ibsen show Nora Helmer to fulfil the role of the Victorian woman?

Nora fulfills her duty of being a housewife by buying presents for her children on Christmas and playing with them shows that she immensely love her children. She also tries to please her husband by decorating the house for Christmas and obeys his advice to “control her spending habits”. Many of Torvald’s advice for Nora is abstract, when he mentions being acquainted with Krogstad can “poison” their children (as he sees Krogstad as a bad influence on the household), but Nora takes this idea very literally (due to woman’s lack of education in Victorian society in general) and so she is actually scared of her children getting poisoned, because of her, as she has committed a similar crime to Krogstad’s.

2.      In what ways does she not adhere to the role?

She is not completely obedient to her husband as she hides the loan secret from him, and secretly eating macaroons behind him and telling another man about it (Dr Rank). She also tries to persuade her husband to keep the job at the bank for Torvald instead of Mrs Linde for her own benefit. This tells the audience she is not very truthful, which is not the Victorian ideology for women.

3.      In what ways does Ibsen develop Nora’s character to present her complexity? In what ways might this have been a challenge to the audience of the period it was written in?
In the beginning of Act One, the audience sees Nora as a frivolous woman through her responses to Torvald, and a child-like, self-centered and insensitive character through her conversation with Mrs Linde. Nora seems to be a character that seems to have a candid, transparent mind-set at first, as the audience can see her personalities so easily. But towards the end of Act One, the audience learns that Nora bears a secret with her, borrowing a loan to help her husband in need, and her conversation with Mrs Linde builds up the dramatic tension within Nora, her internal conflict between her childish nature and her need to grow out of it.
In Act Two, the audience can see more of Nora’s internal conflict as her worry about her “poisoning” her children grows. She expresses this worry with her nursemaid. She also confides her personal matters with Dr Rank. All these events lead to the ultimate revelation of Nora’s secret in borrowing the loan from Krogstad and forging her father’s signature to Mrs Linde. Nora keeps the secret of Krogstad’s letter to her husband till the end, causing her to worry the whole time during her dance with Torvald. At the end of Act Two, Nora reveals the dramatic irony by confirming to her husband, “(I) am dancing as though (my) life depend on it”.


4.      What elements might have shocked a Victorian audience in Act 2?
·         How she wants to leave the house without consulting with Torvald – women do not have power to make her own decisions in society without her husband
·         Her insistence on letting Krogstad stay and how she calls him “petty” – women are not supposed to devalue a men’s pride
·         How she lets Dr. Rank see her stockings and “a bit higher up” – a married woman cannot show her inner stockings to other men
·         She knows about Dr. Rank liking her but completely ignores it – a married woman has to stay loyal to the man she married

5.      Does Ibsen build empathy for Nora in Act 2? If so, in what ways?
Ibsen builds empathy for Nora for the modern audience. The modern audience would support Nora’s choice to disobey the Victorian ideology for woman is motivated by her love for her family members. This highlights to the audience Nora’s good-natured character. as her maturity evolves from the end of Act One to the end of the play, helping her to understand more of the society around her, which influence her responses to her life situations (i.e leave the house on her husband), although are morally just (as the modern audience understands her motivations), are not accepted by Victorian society at the time, making the modern audience to feel sympathy for her even more.

6.      Ibsen parallels some themes with other subplots in the play for example lies and deception, breaking the law, poisoning one’s offspring, if someone goes away – everyone will soon get used to it. Name which parts in the play it occurs and the effects it has on the audience.
·        Lies & Deception: Macaroons, Secret of her borrowing money, Lying some part of the secret to Mrs Linde
·        Breaking the law: during the first conversation between Nora and Krogstad
·        Poisoning one’s offspring: When Nora insists Torvald to let Krogstad stay in the bank and Torvald refused
·        If someone goes away – everyone will soon get used to it: during Nora’s conversation with the nursemaid and Dr. Rank in Act 2

No comments: