Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Van's essay


Essay: How does the Sophocles foreshadow the tragedy at the end of the play through connecting the play with the citizens’ beliefs?
In the play Antigone, written by Sophocles, the mention of Gods in characters’ speeches as well as in the chorus highlights the strong religious beliefs in Gods within the Greek citizens of Thebes. By connecting the devices of characterisation of Creon and Antigone, and chorus with the beliefs of the citizens of Thebes, Sophocles is able to emphasise the device of prolepsis of the tragedy at the end of the play.
Creon’s characterisation is portrayed as self-motivated and egotistic through his argument with Haemon about Antigone’s action. As the quarrel continues, Creon states, “Am I to rule this land for others – or myself?” The diction of “myself” explicitly clarifies his selfishness as a king is expected to always consider for his citizens, not for himself. The constant use of hyperbole in his speeches such as through the phrase, “she destroys cities” (exaggerating Antigone’s crime) explains that by devaluing people around him, Creon can feel the importance of an authority satisfying his ego. However, the Greek people believe that Gods consider ego along with selfishness as a sin. The chorus implicitly mentions about “delusion, blithe” and “ . . . unaware till he trips and puts his foot into the fire” which implies the result of ego. The words “delusion” and “blithe” demonstrate that ego blinds Creon and hallucinated him with his content in being an absolutely powerful king with all the people of Thebes being under his control. Nevertheless, the use of ellipsis acts as a turning point in the speech as the outcome of ego is revealed within the chorus’s mind. Creon then will then become from “unaware” to aware as “he trips” but the realisation is too late which results to “foot in fire” which implies the punishment Creon will receive which is to lose all of his family members. The punishment by God serves as an irony due to the fact that Creon is also the one who insults Antigone’s family members, her brother, Polynices. Consequently, the belief is illustrated that the payback price is determined by the same degree of sin committed (ego). 

Anitgone is a rebellious woman character against Creon, the king of Thebes, due to her strong beliefs in Gods. She violated Creon’s law being aware that the punishment will certainly be dead. During her conversation with Ismene, she states that, “death will be glory” for her which suggests that Antigone believes that Gods witness everything and will glorify her for actions. The belief of Gods watching everything in Greece can also be the reason leading to democracy as there is no point in hiding the true feelings while God knows everything. Therefore, Antigone bravely admits her action violating the laws with pride. The Greek audience would also agree with Antigone as Greek people believe a mortal human can never be compared or even win over the Gods which devalues Creon in the audience’s eye creating dramatic irony – builds up sympathy towards Antigone. Nonetheless, although the chorus mentions about Antigone’s being the “last root” highlighting her toughness, there is no praise for Antigone in the chorus’s speeches. Even though Haemon reports about the rumours of Antigone deserving glory while the audience may find the source unreliable due to his passionate love with Antigone, there is no real evidence that the Greek citizens praising her actions. On the other hand, the speech after Antigone being escorted out of the palace takes place when Creon is present, which may outline that the chorus’s real thoughts are still locked by fear for Creon as no one dares to taking on Antigone’s side. If that is the real situation, Haemon’s report of the rumours can possibly be true hinting that Creon will change his mind of not killing Antigone. However, because every citizen is overcome by fear except for Haemon, it forebodes that Creon may not be able to save Antigone in time which also foreshadows the following death of Haemon. 

Overall, the device of prolepsis is portrayed successfully by Sophocles by connecting the Greek beliefs with the play. Through the characterisation fo Creon and Antigone, and the use of chorus, every punishment and outcome of the play can be predicted adding dramatic tension to the scenes within the play as the audience may expect something else or proving their predictions are right which attracts the audience’s attention throughout the entire play.



No comments: